A new email from the federal Environmental Protection Agency says the water wells for 19 affected families in Dimock, PA have tested fine and do not pose a threat to those families. Yet, some of those families are still grabbing headlines by playing the victim, claiming their water is undrinkable. Who to believe?
The Dimock situation is difficult to understand, being shrouded in so many layers of publicity stunts it’s hard to know what the real story is. As near as MDN can tell, in a nutshell:
- Several years ago Cabot Oil & Gas drilled Marcellus gas wells in the Dimock area.
- Dimock is known to have methane (natural gas) in local well water supplies, prior to Cabot’s drilling.
- However, the state DEP says that Cabot did not properly case several of those wells, and it caused methane to leak into nearby water wells for 19 families.
- Cabot denies that it improperly cased the wells, and has maintained their innocence from the beginning.
- Cabot was instructed to provide potable water to the homes, and to install water methane filtering systems for all of the homes, which they did.
- Cabot wants to stop trucking the water because the filtering systems work and make the water free of methane, suitable for use.
- However, at least some of the families refuse to allow testing to be done by Cabot, apparently preferring to continue playing victim, grabbing headlines, and suing Cabot.
- The state DEP, and federal EPA, have tested the water and concluded it’s fine to use, and that Cabot can now stop trucking water.
And now, headlines emblazon newspapers, interviewing affected family members that are “horrified” that Cabot will be allowed to stop trucking water. Nearby mayor of Binghamton, NY, Matt Ryan, is volunteering to send water to Dimock (wonder how the already over-taxed taxpayers of Binghamton will like that one). A press conference in New York City and subsequent bus trip (using evil fossil fuels) to Dimock have been scheduled to call attention to the “plight” of the families in Dimock. It all appears to be a PR stunt.
Here is the text of an email sent to Dimock residents on Friday, Dec. 2 from the federal EPA:
Subject: Follow-up status re: Nov 10, 2011 visit with Dimock PA residents
Dear Dimock Residents,
This email is a follow-up to the visits to Dimock area homes by EPA on November 10, 2011 and the subsequent review of well sampling data for wells impacted by the Cabot Oil and Gas Company drilling activities. EPA has conducted a preliminary review and screening of the data provided by the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection and residents. While we are continuing our review, to date, the data does not indicate that the well water presents an immediate health threat to users. EPA will continue to review available information related to the concerns of Dimock area residents. We are continuing to work with the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania going forward on this issue.
Please feel free to call me or David Polish, Community Involvement Coordinator, at (215) 814-3327, if you have further questions.
Trish Taylor, Community Involvement Coordinator
Hazardous Site Cleanup Division (Mailcode 3HS52)
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Region 3
1650 Arch Street, Philadelphia, PA., 19103
phone: (215) 814 – 5539
fax: (215) 814 – 3015
If you have first-hand knowledge of what’s happening with the affected families in Dimock, feel free to leave a comment and update us.