Chesapeake Settles Royalty Lawsuit in TX; Implications for PA?
Landowners in Pennsylvania have been upset with shenanigans by Chesapeake Energy in shorting them out of royalties for years. In 2013 a group of landowners in Bradford County, PA filed a lawsuit against Chesapeake over the royalty issue (see Bradford County, PA Landowners Sue Chesapeake over Royalties). Since that time a number of lawsuits have popped up in PA against Chesapeake over the same issue (see Judge Rules Royalty Lawsuit Against Chesapeake in PA Continues). PA is not the only state where landowners have problems with Chesapeake’s royalty calculations. Another such case was filed in Texas in 2013–and Chesapeake just settled that case out of court…
Read More “Chesapeake Settles Royalty Lawsuit in TX; Implications for PA?”
Midstream giant Williams and drilling giant Chesapeake Energy are cuddling a little bit closer in the Ohio Utica Shale. Williams announced today they have signed an agreement with Chesapeake to run gathering pipelines in a new area of the dry gas Utica for Chesapeake in return for signing a contract that binds Chessy to using Williams until 2035. Williams was already gathering natural gas for Chessy on 140,000 acres of Utica Shale land in Ohio. This agreement extends the time on that 140,000 acres by adding another 20 years, and adds another 50,000 acres to the mix…
Welcome to Friday. It’s time for a brief tutorial on “short selling” or “going short” in the stock market. Even if you don’t participate in the stock market, you need to pay attention if you work for a Marcellus driller or other publicly traded company that sells to or is part of the industry. You also need to pay attention if you are leased with a Marcellus driller. A company’s stock price is key to the value of the company–something called its market capitalization. The more a company is worth (the more “market cap” it has) the more it can borrow when it needs to for things like drilling new wells. A bigger market cap also means a company can borrow money at a lower interest rate (more collateral/value, less risk). Let’s take a look at the recent market gyrations and how those gyrations have encouraged something called short selling of Marcellus-related stocks…
Yesterday the Pennsylvania Dept. of Environmental Protection announced an agreement/settlement with three Marcellus drillers operating in the northeastern portion of the state. The three–Chesapeake Energy, XTO Energy and SWEPI (i.e. Shell) were fined a collective $374,481 for methane migration related to their drilling activities at three locations (three different counties) in 2011 and 2012. The bad news is that 13 private water wells between the three incidents were negatively affected, along with several local creeks. The good news is that the problems are all fixed. Methane migration is an eminently fixable condition. Here are the details for each fine, including what happened and where it happened…
An unfortunate decision in an Ohio court case may have far-reaching implications for Ohio landowners. In Armstrong v. Chesapeake Exploration, L.L.C., landowners Myron and Nikki Armstrong purchased 61 acres of land in Tuscarawas County, OH in 2003 with an existing oil and gas lease (dating back to 1972). After purchasing the property, the Armstrong’s land was pooled into a drilling unit and a well was drilled. We do not know how much (or even if) the well produced in the way of gas and oil. We don’t know if it was hooked up to a pipeline for production. We assume it was hooked up and is producing because the Armstrongs have sued to cancel the lease saying they haven’t received a single royalty check since the well was drilled. Tuscarawas County Court ruled that because there is no express provision in the original lease saying “you can cancel this lease if we don’t pay you the royalties we say we’ll pay you,” the court ruled in favor of Chesapeake and the company that owns the lease and is supposed to pay the royalties–Belden & Blake. The Armstongs appealed the decision to the Ohio Court of Appeals, Fifth Appellate District. That court has just ruled the same way–saying even though royalties haven’t been paid, that’s not a good and sufficient reason to cancel the lease…
Chesapeake Energy released their second quarter 2015 operating and financial results today. Chessy, as you know, is a big company involved in a number of shale plays–although the Ohio Utica and the Pennsylvania Marcellus are its biggest and most important areas of operation. The good news: Chessy’s OH Utica production increased by 13% from 1Q15–even while curtailing much of their Utica production. Overall, across all of their shale plays, converting oil and natural gas into barrels of oil equivalent production, Chesapeake held the line. In 2Q14 they produced 63.2 million barrels of oil equivalent per day (mmboed) of production, and 63.9 mmboed in 2Q15. The company continued to lower costs over the past year–so it stands to reason if you produce and sell the same amount but lower costs, you make more in profit, right? Wrong. Prices the company received for both oil and natural gas collapsed over the past year. In 2Q14 Chesapeake got an average $2.45 per thousand cubic feet (Mcf) for their natural gas. In 2Q15? They got a piddly $1.01/Mcf. Ouch. You can understand why net income (which includes expenses) swung from $371 million in the black for 2Q14 to $5.6 BILLION in the red (a loss) in 2Q15. No wonder Wall Street is telling Chesapeake to sell itself (see today’s companion story)…
The buyout sharks are circling midstream behemoth Williams, as we reported yesterday (see 
Traffic along an extended stretch of two Ohio highways in Columbiana County, OH was closed for nearly five hours on April 23 because a drilling rig that was moved leaked “a mineral-based synthetic, a non-hazardous drilling oil compound” for 27 miles as it was moved. Ouch. Somebody’s head will roll. The rig was being moved by a contractor for Chesapeake Energy. You might think somebody would notice something leaking over the course of 27 bloody miles! But apparently not. Fortunately the fluid/oil was not toxic or dangerous in any way, other than perhaps slipping on it…
Chesapeake Energy is the second largest natural gas producer in the United States and the largest producer in both the Marcellus and Utica Shale. Yesterday the company released their first quarter 2015 results and held an earnings call with analysts to discuss how things are going for the company. Depending on which media account you read today, you’ll find that Chesapeake is scaling back operations in the Utica Shale while at the same time looking to lease more land in the Utica; their rig count has been decimated and yet production rose 14% year over year; and one source says the company posted a big loss and is burning cash like crazy while another says it isn’t really losing money, costs are dropping and the outlook is improving. Yes, it runs the gamut. Apparently anyone can find about anything to love or hate about Chessy’s latest update. Kind of a like a rorschach test…