Taxation

  • | | |

    PA RINO Rep. Gene DiGirolamo Proposes Marcellus Tax Hike – Again

    Seeking to kill the economic miracle that has been shale gas drilling in Pennsylvania, the so-called “brave” Republican (really a RINO) PA Rep. Gene DiGirolamo is proposing a 4.9% tax on the value of natural gas extracted and sold from state wells. That’s in addition to the impact fee/tax already in place. The new tax would supposedly raise another $640 million of money that politicians like DiGirolamo could get their grubby hands on to parcel out in vote buying schemes (rather than continue to do the hard work begun by Tom Corbett in reigning in spending).

    DiGirolamo has been pedaling higher taxes on Marcellus drilling since at least Sept. 2011 (see Marcellus & Utica Shale Story Links: Thursday, Sep 22, 2011). Such a plan doesn’t stand a prayer of a chance while Republicans hold both houses and the governor’s chair. Which raises the question of why DiGirolamo would float this plan again now. Likely a sleazy political ploy to curry favor with his Democrat friends because he figures they’ll be taking over next year after the election…
    Read More “PA RINO Rep. Gene DiGirolamo Proposes Marcellus Tax Hike – Again”

  • | | | |

    Specifics on Marcellus $ Helping to Clean Chesapeake Bay Pollution

    A month ago MDN brought you the good news that money raised as part of the Marcellus Shale impact fee in PA is being used to launch a project that is hoped will clean up the single largest source of pollution for the Chesapeake Bay–the Old Forge borehole near Scranton, PA (see Marcellus Drilling Helps Fix Biggest Polluter of Chesapeake Bay). The initial story outlines the high level plan by Susquehanna Mining Solutions LLC to build a treatment plant that will convert acid mine water coming from the borehole (some 60-100 million gallons per day) into clean water for other uses.

    The original article was short on specifics. We now have a few of the specifics for how Susquehanna Mining Solutions will perform this miracle. It’s no small task…
    Read More “Specifics on Marcellus $ Helping to Clean Chesapeake Bay Pollution”

  • | | | |

    The Secret Back Room Deal to Raise OH’s Utica Shale Tax

    Ohio’s top two industry trade groups, the Ohio Oil and Gas Association (OOGA) and the Ohio Petroleum Council (OPC) are not “on the same page” when it comes to the Republican raise-taxes-on-Utica-drilling plan 3.0. MDN recently told you about the latest incarnation of Gov. John Kasich’s desire to “spread the wealth around” in classic socialist fashion (see OH Repubs Offer Excuses Why This Time High Utica Taxes are OK). OOGA was in on the secret dealings to craft the latest tax hike (shame on them). OPC was not and so far they’re staying neutral and not giving their support. Not yet anyway. Let’s hope it stays that way.

    The story about OOGA vs OPC in raising Utica Shale taxes:
    Read More “The Secret Back Room Deal to Raise OH’s Utica Shale Tax”

  • | | | |

    OH Repubs Offer Excuses Why This Time High Utica Taxes are OK

    Speaker of the Ohio House William G. Batchelder (Republican-Medina), Speaker Pro Tempore Matt Huffman (Republican-Lima), and other members of the Ohio House Republican Caucus offered their pathetic excuses on why this time it’s a-OK to steal money from Ohio landowners and drilling companies and give it to other residents of Ohio–in the form of an income tax break. Apparently there’s lack of spine to do the right thing and reduce spending in Ohio (although that particular disease is not endemic to Ohio).

    Here’s the Republican so-called leadership’s bland, generic excuses statement about why it’s OK to raise taxes on drilling this time:
    Read More “OH Repubs Offer Excuses Why This Time High Utica Taxes are OK”

  • | | |

    OOGA Caves, Endorses New Higher Tax on OH Utica Shale

    It looks like taxes on the Utica Shale in Ohio will go up. Yesterday OH Rep. Matt Huffman and Speaker William Batchelder (both Republicans) introduced House Bill 375 which would raise taxes on Utica Shale drilling. Efforts have been under way for the past two years by OH Gov. John “foreigner-hunter” Kasich. He’s into socialism these days–raise taxes on one set of people and give it to another. He’s had some assistance from his fellow Republicans in this regard–but the efforts have (thankfully) gone nowhere.

    But now it’s different. This time the Ohio Oil & Gas Association (OOGA), long opposed to raising the Utica Shale tax, has endorsed the latest proposal, which means it’s probably not as much as Kasich wanted, but it’s certainly more that what it is now. Sadly, OOGA has also (for political expediency) endorsed the concept of giving “the extra money” raised by new taxes to voters (i.e. vote buying) in the form of a state income tax cut…
    Read More “OOGA Caves, Endorses New Higher Tax on OH Utica Shale”

  • | | |

    Marcellus Drilling Helps Fix Biggest Polluter of Chesapeake Bay

    Natural gas will help clean up the single largest source of pollution to the Chesapeake Bay. What is that source? Acid mine drainage that pours out of a single hole called the Old Forge borehole drilled by the federal government (Army Corps of Engineers) in 1962. Some 60-100 million gallons of acid mine water pour out of that hole every day–into the Lackawanna River which dumps into the Susquehanna River which empties into the Chesapeake Bay.

    Where does all that water come from (what causes it), and what does natural gas have to do with fixing the problem? Read on…
    Read More “Marcellus Drilling Helps Fix Biggest Polluter of Chesapeake Bay”

  • | | | | |

    PA Dems Continue to Beat the “Tax & Regulate Marcellus” Drum

    Here’s not a surprise: The eight (or ten or twelve) Democrats who have announced they’re running against incumbent Republican PA Gov. Tom Corbett next year want to more than double the taxes on Marcellus Shale drilling and slap super-strict and unnecessary new regulations on drilling. Ever hear of an elected Democrat who wasn’t in love with taking YOUR money and giving it to other people? Or an elected Democrat who doesn’t love micromanaging your life for you–telling you what you can and can’t eat, drink, smoke, do? (Everything except sex–you can have all the risky sex you want.) No, we haven’t either, which is why we NEVER vote for them. EVER.

    We won’t make this an anti-Democrat diatribe–MDN has lots of Dem subscribers (and friends) and we appreciate them all–and we hear from them when we make these kinds of comments. 🙂 Have no fear–we will not cover the upcoming PA governor’s race ad nauseam. However, every now and again we’ll bring you an illustrative story of the PA governor’s race just to remind you of the philosophical Grand Canyon that exists between those who truly support drilling and those who would, by intent or ignorance, crush it with ill-advised over-tax and over-regulate policies…
    Read More “PA Dems Continue to Beat the “Tax & Regulate Marcellus” Drum”

  • | | | |

    MSC to PA Dem Gubernatorial Candidates: Nix the Big Tax Idea

    Most (all?) of the candidates who have announced they are running for the Democrat nomination for governor in Pennsylvania have said they will (a) increase regulation on the Marcellus Shale industry, and (b) dramatically increase taxes on the industry. Democrats either don’t know or don’t care that such taxes suffocate businesses and cause those businesses to go elsewhere. It’s a fact, not a threat.

    The Marcellus Shale Coalition (MSC)–a group of some of the biggest drillers and midstream companies in the Marcellus–have weighed in and are giving PA’s Democrat gubernatorial candidates a verbal slap about their plans to tax and regulate…
    Read More “MSC to PA Dem Gubernatorial Candidates: Nix the Big Tax Idea”

  • | | | | |

    PA Anti-Fracking Gatecrashers Outside, Real Work Gets Done Inside

    We know everyone likes a good story, so… Once upon a time there were four anti-drillers: Craig Stevens (from Dimock, PA, he of the little brown jug that supposedly contains contaminated drinking water from his well but he won’t let anyone test it); Ray Kemble (also from Dimock, PA); Robert Lee McCaslin (from Bath, NY); and Randy Moyer (from Portage, PA). None of these anti-drillers apparently have day jobs because they travel around the northeast like groupies following their favorite rock band–except in reverse. This band of merry anti-frackers travel about the countryside trying to gatecrash pro-drilling meetings. (Every now and again they do attend a meeting of the anti-drilling faithful–just to get some good juju to keep going.)

    Anywho…our merry band of four anti-frackers descended on a peaceful meeting of elected PA officials in far western PA yesterday, and the Washington Observer-Reporter was there to report on the four anti-frackers outside instead of the 100 elected officials inside…
    Read More “PA Anti-Fracking Gatecrashers Outside, Real Work Gets Done Inside”

  • | | |

    WV Lawmaker Trip to ND to Study Drill Tax Cost $25K

    A few weeks ago MDN told you about 18 West Virginia legislators who were due to fly to North Dakota for an overnighter to study that states Legacy Fund–money set aside by ND from shale drilling taxes and fees to benefit the state in the future. Some WV legislators want to set up a similar fund, called a Future Fund, and they figured the best way to do so was to conduct a junket to ND for some prominent (and not yet convinced) lawmakers. MDN pointed out it would be a heck of a lot cheaper to fly a couple of ND officials to WV than the other way around (see 18 WV Lawmakers Flying to ND for a $20K Overnighter on Drill Tax).

    It seems the Charleston Gazette agrees with MDN. They also say it was 19 legislators (not 18) that went on the trip, they stayed for two nights not one, and they got a $55 per-diem for meals. Total bill estimated to be something like $25K. Sure pays to be a WV legislator…
    Read More “WV Lawmaker Trip to ND to Study Drill Tax Cost $25K”

  • | | |

    Partisan PA Budget & Policy Center Pushes Extreme Tax on Marcellus

    Look at this asinine headline from the Philadelphia Tribune: “Policy Center reports Marcellus Shale not beneficial.” And this equally asinine opening sentence: “Pennsylvania Budget and Policy Center – a nonpartisan policy research that provides analytical data on a host of statewide initiatives – has waded into the controversial Marcellus Shale drilling in the state…” The PA Budget and Policy Center (PBPC) is anything but nonpartisan. It is an extreme leftist, partisan, liberal organization where anything that moves or breathes (and even if it doesn’t move or breathe) needs to be taxed so politicians can use the money for their own walking-around purposes. In keeping with their philosophy, the PBPC’s prescription for Marcellus Shale drilling in PA is to ramp up the tax on it–or it’s no good. No benefit at all for PA residents.

    What utter absurdity. Did the PBPC even bother to visit places like Susquehanna County, PA before making such ludicrous pronouncements? We doubt it…
    Read More “Partisan PA Budget & Policy Center Pushes Extreme Tax on Marcellus”

  • | | | | |

    Pipelines Lower Taxes in Some Ohio School Districts

    New York is perhaps the most taxed state in the Union. When MDN editor Jim Willis tells people that his school and property taxes went down–because of a single shale pipeline and compressor plant recently built in the township where he lives–they look at him like he’s gone mad. Who ever heard of taxes going down anywhere in New York State? But it’s true!

    School districts (and taxpayers) in Ohio are now learning about the benefits of pipelines. Because of revenue generated from taxes on pipelines, school taxes are heading down in some Ohio school districts. And that’s even without Gov. John Kasich’s “spread the wealth around” higher severance tax…
    Read More “Pipelines Lower Taxes in Some Ohio School Districts”

  • | | |

    18 WV Lawmakers Flying to ND for a $20K Overnighter on Drill Tax

    West Virginia Senate President Jeff Kessler really really wants the WV legislature to set up a rainy day fund or “WV Future Fund” with some of the severance tax money raised from shale drilling in the state, so this week he’s flying himself and 17 other state lawmakers to North Dakota for an overnighter to hear from ND leaders about how their “Legacy Fund” has worked in that state. Total cost to WV taxpayers: $18,000 – $20,000.

    Er, why are they not flying one or two ND officials to Wild, Wonderful WV to make the presentation–for $2,000? Best not to ask such questions of the political ruling class…
    Read More “18 WV Lawmakers Flying to ND for a $20K Overnighter on Drill Tax”

  • | | | | |

    PA Drillers Pay $1B+ in Taxes/Fees, Democrats Want More

    In the first two years of Pennsylvania’s impact fee–which is really 60% fee and 40% tax–the state has collected $406.7 million from drillers. Since Marcellus Shale drilling began in earnest in 2008, drillers have ponied up more than $500 million to repair PA roadways. Add to that permit fees, state corporate taxes and state income taxes and all told, drilling companies have paid out well over a billion dollars in PA–a staggering number.

    However, more than a billion dollars is still not enough for PA’s Democrat politicians who continue to agitate for a severance tax to grant them an open spigot of money to spend as they please. Their insatiable appetite to spend other people’s money seemingly knows no bounds…

    Natural gas companies fixed or are repairing at least 413 miles of state roads in Susquehanna, Wyoming and Wayne counties, mostly damaged by their heavy trucks, a Times-Tribune review of state Department of Transportation records show.

    The industry spent more than $500 million statewide on repair and replacement projects on state roads since the natural gas boom began, said Kathryn Klaber, chief executive officer of the Marcellus Shale Coalition. That does not include nearly $406.7 million in impact fees the state Public Utility Commission said natural gas drillers were required to pay to counties over the same period, but critics say the industry still isn’t paying its fair share.

    “That’s not something we should celebrate,” said state Rep. Mike Carroll, D-Hughestown. “They’re doing what they should be doing. That should be a given.”

    There have been some instances in which PennDOT has had trouble getting the companies to conduct repairs, said Terry McHenry, a PennDOT district inspection manager, but “by and large, they have been pretty darn good.”

    Before drillers can put their heavy trucks on many state roads, natural gas companies are required to take out insurance policies amounting to $12,500 per mile, McHenry said.

    PennDOT conducts weekly inspections on bonded roads and requires natural gas companies to repair damage they caused.

    When there is damage, McHenry said companies submit a maintenance repair plan to PennDOT and pay contractors to fix the roads.

    In many cases, he said drillers leave the roads in better shape than they found them.

    “In the end, I think we will have – in most cases, not in all cases – a better roadway system than before they got here,” McHenry said.

    The industry also sometimes reconstructs roads before work in an area begins to gain better access to gas wells, said Klaber. In those cases, the industry wants to ensure it is not paying for damage caused by other major users of the same roads, she said.

    Carroll said he still has concerns about roads not necessarily associated with Marcellus Shale communities being damaged by heavy trucks and not getting the appropriate funding to repair that damage. For example, he said trucks carrying equipment and water may travel through Lackawanna and Luzerne counties on Interstate 81.

    Klaber said other industries that send vehicles such as delivery trucks and school buses are not asked to pay additional fees for damaging public roads.

    “We should celebrate economic activity” that keeps the roads occupied, she said.

    State Rep. Sid Michaels Kavulich, D-Taylor, like several other of his Democratic colleagues from the region’s legislative delegation, said he appreciates the industry’s work on roads.

    At the same time, Pennsylvanians need to learn from the legacy of the coal mining industry, he said.

    That means getting fair value for the natural resource the industry extracts from the commonwealth for its citizens and additionally require the industry to put aside money for cleanup of environmental contamination.

    Taylor still suffers from mining subsidence years later, Kavulich said, adding he fears the state is not doing enough to ensure the industry is held financially accountable for environmental impacts.

    The House members, along with state Sen. John Blake, D-Archbald, each expressed support for a natural gas severance tax.

    Pennsylvania is the only state in the nation with major natural gas production that does not have a severance tax, Blake said. He called the impact fees “woefully inadequate.”

    Kavulich said the impact fees levied on the industry currently translate to about a 1 percent tax, and he would support a “moderate” severance tax of 3 percent to 4 percent as some neighboring states have.

    A Pennsylvania Budget and Policy Center report found that despite low market prices, the economic value of natural gas increased from $1.6 billion to $3.9 billion between the second half of 2010 and the second half of 2012.

    The organization found that the impact fees remained flat despite that, while a 4 percent natural gas severance tax like West Virginia’s could generate between $434 million and $490 million in 2013-14 – about twice as much as the center’s $228 million to $229 million impact fee projections.

    That money could be invested in areas like education and health and human services, in addition to fixing damaged infrastructure, Kavulich said.

    A severance tax would make Pennsylvania less competitive, Klaber said, and the Pennsylvania Budget and Policy Center’s estimates do not account for lost revenue from drillers ceasing operations in response.

    She said investment would slow in response to a new tax, and many companies were already hurt by retroactive impact fees, resulting in lost capital investment.

    “Northeast Pennsylvania would be the hardest hit by a severance tax,” she said.

    Klaber argued that the industry already has given taxpayers value in return for extracting natural gas through hundreds of millions of dollars worth of gas leases for state-owned property.

    In addition to the leases, impact fees, investments on state roads, she said the industry also pays state corporate taxes and permitting fees, while its employees pay state income taxes.

    “This industry has paid its way in many different ways,” Klaber said.*

    *Wilkes-Barre (PA) The Citizens’ Voice (Jul 22, 2013) – Natural gas industry routinely fixing state roads

  • | | |

    Cincy Paper Targets OH Republicans for Not Supporting High Tax

    Retribution: Time to make the brave Republicans in the Ohio House pay for not supporting the socialist concept of “spreading the wealth around” to people who didn’t earn it by supporting a high severance tax on Utica Shale drilling. A new hit piece in the Cincinnati Enquirer tries to do just that–by proclaiming that “big oil & gas” has “pumped” a (measly) $660,000 in campaign contributions to Ohio House legislators, most of them Republican. Implication: They were bought off.

    What utter folly…
    Read More “Cincy Paper Targets OH Republicans for Not Supporting High Tax”

  • | | |

    PA Landowners with Marcellus Wells: The (Property) Tax Man Cometh

    A developing story for Pennsylvania landowners, as reported by WTAE Channel 4 (ABC) Pittsburgh: If you’re a PA landowner with over 10 acres of farmland or woodlands, it’s likely you pay a much lower tax rate on the land because of the “Clean and Green” Act–technically known as the Pennsylvania Farmland and Forest Land Assessment Act of 1974. Clean and Green is meant to keep taxes on farms and other agricultural-types of property lower, based on the land’s value for agriculture, rather than taxed on the land’s prevailing or “full market” value. When the land’s use changes, however, to something like an industrial use (i.e. used for a drill pad), the landowner is responsible for paying higher taxes on the prevailing market value for that portion of land used for that purpose.

    If you haven’t been paying a higher tax rate for the portion of your land used for drilling (as we understand it, only the surface portion used–where there’s a drill pad), you may retroactively owe back taxes. It seems that the Clean and Green tax issue for landowners with Marcellus wells on their property is now heating up, and if you’re not paying the higher tax, it’s being spun that you’re “hurting ordinary taxpayers”…
    Read More “PA Landowners with Marcellus Wells: The (Property) Tax Man Cometh”