| | | |

PA Town Delays Accepting Apex Offer of $1,500/Ac + 16% Royalty

Yesterday, MDN told you about a very small lease deal on offer for North Huntingdon Township in Westmoreland County, PA (see Apex Energy Offers $1,500/Ac + 16% Royalty in Westmoreland Co.). Apex Energy wants to lease 4.5 acres of town land for a signing bonus of $6,760. The deal on the table from Apex is “only good” through June 30. Sign now before this offer expires! Town commissioners were not impressed with the high-pressure sales tactic and voted to table a decision on the offer until after June 30.
Read More “PA Town Delays Accepting Apex Offer of $1,500/Ac + 16% Royalty”

| | | |

Apex Energy Offers $1,500/Ac + 16% Royalty in Westmoreland Co.

We’re always interested in lease signing bonuses and royalty rates. We don’t see as many references today as we did five and ten years ago. Typically, we learn about lease rates when municipal-owned land is leased, as is the case for a small parcel in North Huntingdon, PA (Westmoreland County). Apex Energy is offering North Huntingdon $1,500 per acre in a signing bonus to lease 4.5 acres of town land for a grand total of $6,760. It ain’t much, but it’s better than a sharp stick in the eye, right?
Read More “Apex Energy Offers $1,500/Ac + 16% Royalty in Westmoreland Co.”

| | | | | | |

Ohio About to Net $60+ Million for Drilling Under State Parks

check is in the mail

A request by the Ohio Office of Budget and Management (OBM) to set up two new bank accounts to accept payments from drillers is the tipoff that drilling is about to begin under some of Ohio’s state land, including state parks. The state will receive nearly $60 million in lease signing bonus payments to drill under Salt Fork State Park (in Guernsey County), Valley Run Wildlife Area (in Carroll County), and the Zepernick Wildlife Area (in Columbiana County). The vast majority of that is for drilling under Salt Fork.
Read More “Ohio About to Net $60+ Million for Drilling Under State Parks”

| | | | | |

4th Circus’ Final “Screw You” to MVP in Va. Eminent Domain Case

In a clear case of sour grapes for the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit (4th Circus clowns) who tried to block the 303-mile Mountain Valley Pipeline (MVP) by rendering arbitrary decisions that caused years of delays for the pipeline, the court flipped the bird to MVP one last time in a decision issued Tuesday of this week (June 11). Three judges from the 4th Circus re-inflated a jury award against MVP for an eminent domain “taking” case in the Bent Mountain, Virginia, area back in May (see 4th Circus Clowns Punish MVP One Last Time via Eminent Domain Case). MVP appealed to the full 4th Circuit to have all judges re-hear the case, called en banc. On Tuesday, the full court refused, allowing the “screw you” decision by the three loser clowns to stand.
Read More “4th Circus’ Final “Screw You” to MVP in Va. Eminent Domain Case”

| |

Mystery Driller Asks Ohio to Lease More of Salt Fork State Park

In February, the Ohio Oil & Gas Land Management Commission (OGLMC) met to award contracts to drill under (not on) several Ohio state parks, including 5,700 acres of the 20,000-acre Salt Fork State Park in Guernsey County (see Ohio Awards Drilling Contracts for State Parks – Salt Fork Surprise). The big news for us was that Encino Energy, which has long coveted the Salt Fork State Park property, did NOT win the contract for it. At some point, Encino pulled its proposal for Salt Fork and instead concentrated on several other parcels. The contract for Salt Fork was awarded to Infinity Natural Resources. This just in… The OGLMC has received a new nomination to drill under another 2,300 acres of Salt Fork State Park.
Read More “Mystery Driller Asks Ohio to Lease More of Salt Fork State Park”

| | | | | | | | |

OH Supreme Court Reverses “Drilled Too Deep” Decision TERA v Rice

Back in the summer of 2020, MDN told you about a lawsuit brought by an Ohio rights owner called TERA, an organization that owns the royalty rights for a number of leases with wells in Belmont County, OH, drilled by different producers, suing the producers for drilling into the Point Pleasant shale layer when the lease only mentions the Utica layer (see OH Landowners Sue Rice, Ascent, XTO, Gulfport for Drilling Too Deep). We have an important update on that lawsuit which potentially affects all Ohio landowners and drillers. Yesterday, the Ohio Supreme Court issued a ruling that overturns a Seventh District Court of Appeals decision upholding a lower court’s ruling in favor of the rights owner. The Ohio Supremes reversed the judgment of the Seventh District and remanded the case back to the trial court for further proceedings.
Read More “OH Supreme Court Reverses “Drilled Too Deep” Decision TERA v Rice”

| | | | | | |

Ohio Landowners Seek Class Action Against Rice/EQT re Royalties

A group of landowners in Belmont County, OH, filed a lawsuit against Rice Drilling (now EQT Corporation) in July 2021, alleging the company had shorted them on royalty payments by (a) selling the gas extracted to an affiliated (instead of unaffiliated) third party, and (b) deducting post-production costs specifically disallowed under the signed contract. Several landowners who are part of what was originally known as the Smith-Goshen Landowners Group have requested a federal court in Ohio to elevate the lawsuit to class-action status.
Read More “Ohio Landowners Seek Class Action Against Rice/EQT re Royalties”

| | | | | | |

4th Circus Clowns Punish MVP One Last Time via Eminent Domain Case

It’s clearly a case of sour grapes for the same three judges from the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit (4th Circus clowns) who tried to block the 303-mile Mountain Valley Pipeline (MVP) by rendering arbitrary decisions that caused years of delays for the pipeline. We’re talking about Judge Stephanie Thacker, appointed by Barack Hussein Obama (she likes to quote from Dr. Seuss books in her opinions); Judge James Wynn, appointed by Barack Hussein Obama; and Chief Judge Roger Gregory, appointed by William Jefferson Clinton. All three are (in our opinion) corrupt and should immediately be impeached and removed from the bench. Congress finally had enough of their judicial malpractice in blocking MVP and passed a law overriding the clowns, signed into law by Joementia last June (see Equitrans Announces Mountain Valley Pipe to Get Completed in 2023). Now that MVP is on the cusp of starting operations, the three clowns took one last swipe at the pipeline they had tried to block. The judges re-inflated a jury award against MVP for an eminent domain “taking” case in the Bent Mountain, Virginia, area. Sour grapes.
Read More “4th Circus Clowns Punish MVP One Last Time via Eminent Domain Case”

| | | |

Ohio Village in Belmont County Offered $7,500/Acre Signing Bonus

Barnesville (Belmont County), OH

It’s not often we get insight into the latest lease offers floating around. Leasing activity is definitely picking up in the Ohio Utica. We came across what has to be one of (if not THE) highest per-acre bonus offers we’ve seen in Ohio. The Village of Barnesville, in Belmont County, sought lease offers for 177 acres of village-owned property. The village received two offers. One of the offers came from Gulfport Energy, which offered $7,500 per acre as a signing bonus plus 20% royalties. Barnesville turned it down!
Read More “Ohio Village in Belmont County Offered $7,500/Acre Signing Bonus”

| | | | | | | |

OH Landowners Appeal Jury Decision Allowing Pt Pleasant Drilling

A royalty case that took nearly four years and hundreds of filings by both sides was finally decided by an Ohio jury in March (see OH Drillers Win Case Against Landowners re Drilling Deeper). The jury found in favor of several drillers (Ascent Resources, Gulfport Energy, Rice Energy) and against the rights owner (TERA II, LLC) in a case where the words “Point Pleasant” were not included in a lease agreement. The drillers drilled into the Point Pleasant, which sits on the border of the Utica, even though, technically, the lease did not allow it. The jury found the landowners did not “reserve their rights” to the Point Pleasant, given its location next to the Utica. The landowners are now appealing the jury decision.
Read More “OH Landowners Appeal Jury Decision Allowing Pt Pleasant Drilling”

| | | | | | |

OH Federal Judge Allows “Drilled Too Deep” Case to Proceed

Here’s a strange one we don’t quite understand. Yet. Two weeks ago we brought you the news that a jury in a federal court had decided a group of Utica shale drillers, including Rice Drilling (now EQT), Ascent Resources, XTO, and Gulfport Energy, were not guilty of “unjust enrichment” by drilling into the Point Pleasant shale layer that sits immediately below the Utica (see OH Drillers Win Case Against Landowners re Drilling Deeper). The very same federal court with the very same federal judge has just denied a request by some of the same drillers to throw out a similar case. In this new case (Honey Crest Acres v. Rice Drilling & Gulfport Energy), the judge is allowing the plaintiffs to proceed to make their case for unjust enrichment against Rice and Gulfport.
Read More “OH Federal Judge Allows “Drilled Too Deep” Case to Proceed”

| |

WV Mineral Rights Group Cut Out Landmen, Deal Direct w/Drillers

Cutting out the middleman

In the early days of the Marcellus/Utica, landowners often formed groups to negotiate lease terms on behalf of all members. It’s a smart move as it tends to deliver better lease terms — more money for a signing bonus, better royalty rates, and better language in the contract. In fact, MDN got its start when editor Jim Willis noticed a group of 300 landowners (many of them farmers) in nearby Deposit, NY, signed a lease deal with XTO Energy for $90 million (see this story). It made more than one millionaire! Some of the leases signed by landowner groups years ago are now expiring and in one case — in Marshall County, WV — group members are once again shopping their land as an entire block, looking for drillers who will give them the best terms.
Read More “WV Mineral Rights Group Cut Out Landmen, Deal Direct w/Drillers”

| | | |

New Resource for WV Landowners on Leasing for Pore Space

In February, MDN brought readers the news that Tenaska, one of the largest privately operated companies in the U.S., is building a carbon capture and sequestration (CCS) hub spanning tens of thousands of acres in Pennsylvania, Ohio, and West Virginia (see Landmen Knocking Doors in PA, OH, WV to Sign for CCS, Pore Rights). Landmen are “knocking on doors again” in all three states, looking to sign up landowners to store carbon dioxide deep underground. The West Virginia Surface Owners’ Rights Association (WVSORA) has done some research and is offering its advice to landowners about leasing pore space.
Read More “New Resource for WV Landowners on Leasing for Pore Space”

| | | | | | | | |

OH Drillers Win Case Against Landowners re Drilling Deeper

Back in the summer of 2020, MDN told you about a lawsuit brought by an Ohio rights owner called TERA, an organization that owns the royalty rights for a number of leases with wells in Belmont County, OH, drilled by different producers, suing the producers for drilling into the Point Pleasant shale layer when the lease only mentions the Utica layer (see OH Landowners Sue Rice, Ascent, XTO, Gulfport for Drilling Too Deep). The case took nearly four years and hundreds of filings by both sides, but last week, a jury found in favor of the drillers (the defendants) and against the rights owner (the plaintiffs). This case likely has far-reaching consequences for landowners and drillers in Ohio.
Read More “OH Drillers Win Case Against Landowners re Drilling Deeper”

| | | | | | | | | |

Ohio Awards Drilling Contracts for State Parks – Salt Fork Surprise

Yesterday, the Ohio Oil & Gas Land Management Commission (OGLMC) met to award contracts to drill under (not on) several Ohio state parks, including the 20,000-acre Salt Fork State Park in Guernsey County. Anti-fossil fuel nutters didn’t disappoint. They showed up and dressed up in burlap bags and silly hats, standing along a wall to protest against the proceeding. Fortunately, the protesters didn’t disrupt or stop the proceeding (they had been threatened with arrest if they did). The big news (for us) is that Encino Energy, which has long coveted the Salt Fork State Park property, did NOT win the contract for it! At some point, Encino pulled its proposal for Salt Fork and instead concentrated on several other parcels. The contract for Salt Fork was awarded to Infinity Natural Resources. We have the complete list of who won which contracts and how much they are paying in signing bonuses and royalties.
Read More “Ohio Awards Drilling Contracts for State Parks – Salt Fork Surprise”

| | | |

Triple Royalties Provision Stripped from WV Bill on Late Payments

Earlier this week, MDN reported on a bill making its way through West Virginia’s legislative sausage-making process (see WV Bill Triples Conventional Well Royalty Payments if Made Late). WV House Bill (HB) 4292 attempts to close a loophole affecting landowners and mineral rights owners with a conventional oil or gas well, some of whom suffer from late or completely missing royalty payments. The bill just got a lobotomy and is pretty much unrecognizable from the original.
Read More “Triple Royalties Provision Stripped from WV Bill on Late Payments”